How do I know if my driveway can be resurfaced instead of replaced?

A contractor needs to inspect the base. If there is no subsidence, cracking is only surface-deep, and drainage works properly, resurfacing is usually possible.

Is resurfacing a shortcut that will fail sooner?

Not if the base is genuinely sound. It only fails early if it is used to paper over a structural problem that needed a proper dig-out.

Does resurfacing work on block paving as well as tarmac?

Block paving is more often re-laid using the existing blocks after regrading the base, rather than resurfaced in the tarmac sense.

Driveway resurfacing vs full replacement: which do you need

Not every tired-looking driveway needs digging out. Cheltenham contractors generally offer two different jobs that get confused with each other: resurfacing, where a new layer goes over an existing sound base, and full replacement, where the old surface and often the sub-base come out entirely.

Resurfacing works when the underlying base is still solid and drains properly, and the problems are cosmetic or surface-level, faded tarmac, worn block paving joints, minor cracking. Full replacement is needed when there is subsidence, poor drainage, tree root damage, or the base was never built to the right depth in the first place.

Resurfacing: faster, less disruptive, cheaper, but only works over a sound base
Replacement: full dig-out, new sub-base and drainage, needed for structural problems
A contractor should inspect and tell you honestly which one your driveway needs

Asking specifically for this distinction when getting quotes helps you compare like for like, since one contractor's resurfacing quote and another's replacement quote will look very different for very different reasons.

What it costs

Resurfacing is generally the cheaper route since it skips excavation and disposal of the old base, but it is only a false economy if the base underneath is not actually sound. Replacement costs more because it involves digging out, removing spoil, and rebuilding the sub-base and drainage from scratch. A contractor should be able to explain on site which category your driveway falls into and why.

Top 3 by our score

Ranked from our published scoring of public Google reviews for driveway paving.

1. BJ Surfacing
4.8★ · 148 reviews

88
2. Grass Scape
4.9★ · 35 reviews

84
3. B E Rudman
4.9★ · 32 reviews

79

Browse all providers

FAQ

How do I know if my driveway can be resurfaced instead of replaced?: A contractor needs to inspect the base. If there is no subsidence, cracking is only surface-deep, and drainage works properly, resurfacing is usually possible.
Is resurfacing a shortcut that will fail sooner?: Not if the base is genuinely sound. It only fails early if it is used to paper over a structural problem that needed a proper dig-out.
Does resurfacing work on block paving as well as tarmac?: Block paving is more often re-laid using the existing blocks after regrading the base, rather than resurfaced in the tarmac sense.

Enquiries submitted through our forms may be shared with partner providers who can complete the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method and are not influenced by referral fees.